Asking a pupil [RSABE / ABEL]
Dear Detlew,
thank you for the answer. I had read the whole article but I am still not getting it
Partial replicate design is a crossover design so we can get S2W (and consequently CVW) and because R is replicated we can also get S2WR (and consequently CVWR).
So why cant we get S2WT (and consequently CVWT) from the following equation:
S2W=(S2WT+S2WR)*2
as we only have one unknown (S2WT)?
"There is an infinite number of combinations of CVwT- and CVwR- values giving the same pooled CVw. We simply don’t – and can’t – know the variance components.
It’s like asking a pupil “We added two numbers and their sum was five. What were the two numbers?” Leaves the pupil – rightly – dazed and confused."
--> Refering to this, if we know that the sum (S2W) is 5 and one other number (S2WR; lets say it is 3), we can get the unknown number (S2WT; in this case we get 2)?
BEQool
thank you for the answer. I had read the whole article but I am still not getting it
Partial replicate design is a crossover design so we can get S2W (and consequently CVW) and because R is replicated we can also get S2WR (and consequently CVWR).
So why cant we get S2WT (and consequently CVWT) from the following equation:
S2W=(S2WT+S2WR)*2
as we only have one unknown (S2WT)?
"There is an infinite number of combinations of CVwT- and CVwR- values giving the same pooled CVw. We simply don’t – and can’t – know the variance components.
It’s like asking a pupil “We added two numbers and their sum was five. What were the two numbers?” Leaves the pupil – rightly – dazed and confused."
--> Refering to this, if we know that the sum (S2W) is 5 and one other number (S2WR; lets say it is 3), we can get the unknown number (S2WT; in this case we get 2)?
BEQool
Complete thread:
- homoscedasticity assumption in RSABE method WinnieH 2023-08-18 08:57 [RSABE / ABEL]
- heteroscedasticity in RSABE (and ABEL) Helmut 2023-08-18 11:23
- heteroscedasticity in RSABE (and ABEL) WinnieH 2023-08-18 13:05
- homoscedasticity assumption in RSABE method BEQool 2023-08-18 12:30
- Asking a pupil d_labes 2023-08-18 14:11
- Asking a pupilBEQool 2023-08-18 17:16
- Asking a pupil d_labes 2023-08-18 14:11
- heteroscedasticity in RSABE (and ABEL) Helmut 2023-08-18 11:23