Fed (failed) → fasting (succeeded) [Design Issues]
Hi Helmut and all,
Could I sanity-check a downside case
Suppose the Sponsor uses the sequences (S1: C -> D -> A -> B; S2: D -> C -> B -> A) and the Fed part fails to show BE while the fasted part passes.
If the sponsor decides to reformulate, my understanding is that this would require starting over, since a new formulation would invalidate both the fed and fasted data. Is that correct?
Alternatively, if the Sponsor believes the fed miss was a play of chance in a study powered at 80%, he can run another fed study with a larger sample while retaining the original fasted results for submission.
How are reviewers likely to view the initial fed failure alongside a clean fasted outcome? Would submitting both studies make the package look problematic, or is this generally acceptable provided the second fed study succeeds?
Could I sanity-check a downside case
Suppose the Sponsor uses the sequences (S1: C -> D -> A -> B; S2: D -> C -> B -> A) and the Fed part fails to show BE while the fasted part passes.
If the sponsor decides to reformulate, my understanding is that this would require starting over, since a new formulation would invalidate both the fed and fasted data. Is that correct?
Alternatively, if the Sponsor believes the fed miss was a play of chance in a study powered at 80%, he can run another fed study with a larger sample while retaining the original fasted results for submission.
How are reviewers likely to view the initial fed failure alongside a clean fasted outcome? Would submitting both studies make the package look problematic, or is this generally acceptable provided the second fed study succeeds?
—
Kind regards,
Mittyri
Kind regards,
Mittyri
Complete thread:
- Sequences of BE study under both fasting and fed studies A.Shtaiwi 2025-09-03 12:40
- Sequences of BE study under both fasting and fed studies ElMaestro 2025-09-04 08:05
- Sequences of BE study under both fasting and fed studies A.Shtaiwi 2025-09-07 05:52
- Fed → fasting Helmut 2025-09-04 08:26
- Fed (failed) → fasting (succeeded)mittyri 2025-09-22 11:01
- Fed (failed) → fasting (succeeded) Helmut 2025-09-23 15:35
- Fed (failed) → fasting (succeeded)mittyri 2025-09-22 11:01
- Sequences of BE study under both fasting and fed studies ElMaestro 2025-09-04 08:05
